Free Tool: AI Debate

5 Rounds to Agreement: How I Made ChatGPT and Claude Debate Until They Converged | VividaPhoto

5 Rounds to Agreement: How I Made ChatGPT and Claude Debate Until They Converged

TL;DR: Built a free, open-source tool called AI Debate that makes ChatGPT and Claude challenge each other’s answers iteratively until they reach consensus. The convergence typically happens in 3-5 rounds, producing insights neither AI generates alone.

Three AI robots discussing the best pizza nearby - Example of AI Debate tool in action where ChatGPT suggests Mario's, Claude mentions it's closed and suggests Giuseppe's instead
AI Debate Pizza Example – Created with AI for illustrative purposes

The Problem: Single AI, Limited Perspective

Every day, millions toggle between ChatGPT and Claude, comparing responses, trying to determine which answer is better. But what if instead of choosing, we could harness both perspectives simultaneously?

Different AI models have different training data, reasoning patterns, and inherent biases. ChatGPT might excel at creative solutions while Claude provides more structured analysis. Why settle for one when iterative debate produces superior results?

The Solution: AI Debate – Convergence Through Iteration

AI Debate orchestrates structured conversations between multiple AI models. The process is elegantly simple yet remarkably effective:

  1. Parallel Questioning: Submit identical queries to both ChatGPT and Claude simultaneously
  2. Cross-Validation: Feed each model’s response to the other for critique and refinement
  3. Iterative Refinement: Continue the exchange for 3-5 rounds until responses converge
  4. Convergence Detection: Jaccard similarity algorithm identifies when consensus is reached
  5. Superior Output: Final answers combine strengths of both models
Two AI robots engaged in collaborative discussion - one friendly-looking robot and one more serious robot exchanging ideas through hand gestures
AI Collaboration Visualization – Created with AI for illustrative purposes

Technical Implementation: Pure Frontend Magic

AI Debate requires zero backend infrastructure. The entire implementation runs in your browser using vanilla JavaScript and HTML5. Users maintain complete control through their own API keys.

// Simplified core debate loop
async function runDebate(question, maxRounds = 5) {
    let claudeResponse = await askClaude(question);
    let gptResponse = await askGPT(question);
    
    for(let i = 0; i < maxRounds; i++) {
        claudeResponse = await askClaude(`${gptResponse}\n\nYour thoughts?`);
        gptResponse = await askGPT(`${claudeResponse}\n\nYour thoughts?`);
        
        if(checkConvergence(claudeResponse, gptResponse)) break;
    }
    
    return {claudeResponse, gptResponse, rounds: i};
}

Key Technical Features

  • No Backend Required: 100% client-side execution
  • BYOK Model: Bring Your Own Keys for security
  • Convergence Algorithm: Jaccard similarity on trigrams
  • Typical Convergence: 3-5 rounds for most queries
  • Single File: Entire tool in one HTML file
Abstract circular arrows converging toward center - visual representation of ideas merging through iterative refinement
Convergence Concept - Created with AI for illustrative purposes

Real-World Applications

AI Debate transforms how we interact with artificial intelligence across multiple domains:

Research & Analysis

Generate comprehensive literature reviews, validate hypotheses through multi-model verification, and explore complex topics from multiple perspectives simultaneously.

Software Development

Code review through multiple AI lenses, architecture decisions validated by different models, and debugging assistance with cross-validated solutions.

Content Creation

Balanced articles incorporating diverse viewpoints, creative writing with iterative refinement, and marketing copy optimized through debate.

Decision Support

Business strategy validated by multiple AI advisors, investment analysis with cross-checked insights, and risk assessment through collaborative AI evaluation.

Discoveries from AI Debates

After extensive testing, several fascinating patterns emerged:

"The debate process reveals each model's unique reasoning style. ChatGPT often provides creative initial solutions, while Claude adds structural refinement. Together, they achieve synthesis neither reaches alone."

Key Observations

  • Complementary Strengths: Models compensate for each other's weaknesses
  • Rapid Convergence: Most debates stabilize within 3-5 iterations
  • Quality Enhancement: Final answers consistently superior to initial responses
  • Bias Reduction: Cross-validation minimizes individual model biases
  • Emergent Insights: Debate generates ideas absent from either model's initial response
Open Source text with code brackets - indicating free availability of AI Debate source code
Open Source Badge - Created with AI for illustrative purposes

Open Source: Build, Fork, Innovate

AI Debate is completely free and open source. No licenses, no restrictions, no hidden costs. The entire codebase is available for anyone to use, modify, or integrate into their projects.

Getting Started in 3 Steps

  1. Download the single HTML file
  2. Add your API keys
  3. Start your first AI debate

The tool works immediately - no installation, no dependencies, no configuration. Open the file in any modern browser and begin orchestrating AI debates instantly.

Future Developments

The current version supports ChatGPT and Claude, but the architecture accommodates expansion:

Planned Features

  • Multi-Model Support: Gemini, Llama, Mistral integration
  • Specialized Formats: Domain-specific debate structures
  • Batch Processing: Queue multiple debates
  • Export Options: Save debate histories in various formats
  • Custom Convergence: Adjustable similarity thresholds

Community Contributions Welcome

AI Debate thrives on community innovation. Whether adding new models, improving convergence algorithms, or creating specialized implementations, your contributions shape the tool's evolution.

Try AI Debate Today

Experience the power of collaborative AI intelligence. In under 5 minutes, you can orchestrate your first debate between ChatGPT and Claude.

What questions deserve multiple AI perspectives?

What insights await in the convergence?

What will you discover when AIs challenge each other?

The tool is ready. The AIs are waiting. Let the debates begin.


Access AI Debate

Built with curiosity by VividaPhoto • August 2025

⚠️ Important Disclaimer

NO WARRANTY: This software is provided "AS IS", without warranty of any kind, express or implied, including but not limited to the warranties of merchantability, fitness for a particular purpose and noninfringement.

USE AT YOUR OWN RISK: In no event shall the authors or copyright holders be liable for any claim, damages or other liability, whether in an action of contract, tort or otherwise, arising from, out of or in connection with the software or the use or other dealings in the software.

API COSTS: You are solely responsible for any costs incurred through the use of OpenAI, Anthropic, or any other third-party APIs. Monitor your usage carefully.

TERMS OF SERVICE: Users must comply with the terms of service of all third-party providers (OpenAI, Anthropic, etc.). The tool's creator is not responsible for any violations.

CONTENT VERIFICATION: AI-generated content should always be independently verified. Do not rely on AI outputs for critical decisions without human review.

SECURITY: API keys are stored locally in your browser. While they never leave your device, you are responsible for their security. Use dedicated API keys with appropriate spend limits.

Note: All images in this article were created with AI for illustrative purposes.